top of page

AI in daily life – Boon or Bane? The Great Debate

  • Writer: Nikita Suratwala
    Nikita Suratwala
  • 3 days ago
  • 3 min read

A few months ago, I found myself in two very different conversations about artificial intelligence within the same week. In the first, a young colleague spoke about AI with the kind of enthusiasm I associate with genuinely transformative technology – how it had changed the way she researched, wrote, and even thought through problems. In the second, a close friend, someone not in technology at all, spoke about AI with real unease – about jobs, about misinformation, about a world where it was becoming harder to tell what was real.


Both conversations stayed with me, and I do not think either person was wrong. That, to me, is the most honest starting point for this debate.


The case for boon

It is hard to argue with the everyday utility of AI at this point. It has woven itself into how we navigate, how we communicate, how we make decisions both small and significant. In my own work, I have seen AI-driven tools meaningfully improve the speed and quality of research, analysis, communication and decision-making. Tasks that once took days now take hours. Patterns that would have taken considerable experience to notice are surfaced almost instantly.


Beyond work, the applications are just as compelling. AI is making healthcare diagnostics faster and more accurate in many cases. It is helping personalise education for students who learn differently. It is enabling accessibility tools that have genuinely changed daily life for people with disabilities. These are not marginal benefits. They are significant improvements in how people live, work, and access opportunity.


The case for bane

And yet, the concerns are not manufactured either. The anxiety around job displacement is real, and I do not think it is helpful to dismiss it with the standard reassurance that new jobs will emerge to replace the old ones. That may well be true over the long run, but the transition is not always smooth, and not everyone is equally equipped to make it.


There is also a quieter concern that I find myself thinking about more often – what constant reliance on AI is doing to our own cognitive habits. When a tool can answer almost any question instantly, draft almost any document competently, and solve almost any well-defined problem efficiently, what happens to our own muscles for sustained thinking, for brainstorming, for sitting with ambiguity, for working through something the hard way? I do not have a confident answer to that yet, and I am not sure anyone does.


Then there are the more structural concerns – around data privacy, algorithmic bias, the spread of convincing misinformation, and the concentration of this technology's development in the hands of a relatively small number of organisations. These are not hypothetical risks. They are already playing out in various forms, and they deserve serious, sustained attention rather than periodic alarm followed by complacency.


Where this leaves us

The more I sit with this debate, the more I think the question "boon or bane" is the wrong question to be asking. It assumes AI is a single, monolithic force with a single net effect on humanity, when in reality it is a tool, an extraordinarily powerful one whose impact depends heavily on how it is built, deployed, regulated, and used.


A hammer is neither good nor bad. It depends on what it builds and what it is used to break. AI is a far more complex tool than a hammer, but the underlying principle is not entirely different. The technology itself does not have a moral direction. The choices we make around it do.


I do not think we are at a point where we can declare AI a boon or a bane with any real confidence, and I am somewhat suspicious of anyone who claims certainty either way. What I do believe is that the outcome is not predetermined. It will be shaped by the regulatory frameworks we build, the ethical guardrails we insist on, and importantly, by how thoughtfully each of us chooses to integrate these tools into our own lives and work.


Would love to hear your views.


Comments


SIGN UP AND STAY UPDATED!

Thanks for submitting!

© 2024 by Shobhit Agarwal

bottom of page